Table of Contents
回复内容:
Home Backend Development PHP Tutorial Yii 2和Laravel 5,哪个更适合企业/团队使用?

Yii 2和Laravel 5,哪个更适合企业/团队使用?

Jun 06, 2016 pm 04:45 PM
laravel php thinkphp yii yii2

首先说一下团队情况,PHP开发者大约20~30人,前端大约10人,总共开发/维护几十个项目,其中大约70%是内部使用的项目。提供外部使用的项目对PHP性能要求不是很高,所以性能方面不用做过多的考虑。

最近在进行框架选型,之前使用的是ThinkPHP,用了几年,但是随着业务需要,TP不太符合要求了,希望换一个框架,在Yii 2和Laravel 5中选择。

参考问题:yii2和laravel哪个是未来? - PHP 框架

回复内容:

yii和laravel目前来看,都是php最好的框架,laravel的优势是比较好写出工整的代码,这源自于其卓越的设计模式。yii的优势是非常良好的扩展性和极其稳定的性能,天生就为大型项目而生。
此外,laravel一直在吸收最先进的设计思想,因此变化更新很快,laravel5和laravel4有很大区别,yii至今就两个版本,变化不是很大,但是扩展性很好,性能也很好,安全性也是通过了考验的。
有鉴于你是做大型企业项目开发的,对扩展性,稳定性和团队作战要求比较高,综合比下来,yii是不二的选择。 如果换掉就能解决问题的话,我觉得应该把CTO/CEO换掉。 亲,用那么新的干嘛?laravel4就可以了。
多看看框架的社区热度,模块的贡献者的数量与质量。框架本身没啥东西,社区很重要。而且,你们团队里面 一定要有吃的透的人在,不然人数再多也是白搭。白搭。 从团队开发角度而言,我认为是挺不错的,
编辑器友好(秀vim之流的不加插件去写写python吧),
严格的OOP,
命名严格规范,
原生支持的功能丰富,
组件可替代性,
扩展库丰富。

缺点?
耦合性高?谁要你用它的V层了?纯api式的开发不行?系统架构设计不行就不要BB!
可能是学习成本高吧?(而我并未觉得。吃这门饭的,没这精钢钻,莫揽瓷器活,看懂底层确实有点难度)
性能? 又不是没见过用Yii做赌博类的系统,自己脑补那种系统的pv和并发!

ps:
那些喜欢个人solo的就另当别论了!谈优雅的你们也是够了!
企业要的是性能稳定,开发效率快速,规范统一便于维护!
什么代码优雅不优雅的,可以走开了!
业务代码写的不优雅,也是你们自己理解错了框架的特性,要么就是水平有限!
你们知道不按规范来写代码是件多么没协作表现的事情吗?
代码写的漂不漂亮的责任在于写代码的个人水平,不在框架。
企业本来就是个牺牲个性换统一效率的地方!
这还是不是企业级开发了? 耍什么个人开发主义?
给别人擦屁股没擦够过吗?我是擦够了!

我怎么觉得laravel除了路由是特亮点(可以混合模式)外,其他的Yii都有了!
laravel的路由好像django,有时候想到那种DIY化的url配置可能顶天的时候,我整个人都不好了! 建议使用YII框架,目前国内某大型理财P2P产品(曾所在团队),包括自己目前创业中几个产品都是使用的YII框架,当然目前自己使用的是YII2.协作及模块化非常OK.
Laravel也不错的,问题是,哪一个比较适合自己和比较容易团队上手协作. 何不试试 Symfony2 看下源码,挑喜欢的? yii2 Laravel 学之者生,用之者死 首先Laravel 5比Laravel 4提高很多。其次Laravel框架非常适合团战~~基本上是php框架中最合理的架构了。
Statement of this Website
The content of this article is voluntarily contributed by netizens, and the copyright belongs to the original author. This site does not assume corresponding legal responsibility. If you find any content suspected of plagiarism or infringement, please contact admin@php.cn

Hot AI Tools

Undresser.AI Undress

Undresser.AI Undress

AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover

AI Clothes Remover

Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Undress AI Tool

Undress AI Tool

Undress images for free

Clothoff.io

Clothoff.io

AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap

Video Face Swap

Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1

Notepad++7.3.1

Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version

SublimeText3 Chinese version

Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6

Dreamweaver CS6

Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version

SublimeText3 Mac version

God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

Hot Topics

Java Tutorial
1662
14
PHP Tutorial
1262
29
C# Tutorial
1235
24
Laravel Introduction Example Laravel Introduction Example Apr 18, 2025 pm 12:45 PM

Laravel is a PHP framework for easy building of web applications. It provides a range of powerful features including: Installation: Install the Laravel CLI globally with Composer and create applications in the project directory. Routing: Define the relationship between the URL and the handler in routes/web.php. View: Create a view in resources/views to render the application's interface. Database Integration: Provides out-of-the-box integration with databases such as MySQL and uses migration to create and modify tables. Model and Controller: The model represents the database entity and the controller processes HTTP requests.

Laravel user login function Laravel user login function Apr 18, 2025 pm 12:48 PM

Laravel provides a comprehensive Auth framework for implementing user login functions, including: Defining user models (Eloquent model), creating login forms (Blade template engine), writing login controllers (inheriting Auth\LoginController), verifying login requests (Auth::attempt) Redirecting after login is successful (redirect) considering security factors: hash passwords, anti-CSRF protection, rate limiting and security headers. In addition, the Auth framework also provides functions such as resetting passwords, registering and verifying emails. For details, please refer to the Laravel documentation: https://laravel.com/doc

The Continued Use of PHP: Reasons for Its Endurance The Continued Use of PHP: Reasons for Its Endurance Apr 19, 2025 am 12:23 AM

What’s still popular is the ease of use, flexibility and a strong ecosystem. 1) Ease of use and simple syntax make it the first choice for beginners. 2) Closely integrated with web development, excellent interaction with HTTP requests and database. 3) The huge ecosystem provides a wealth of tools and libraries. 4) Active community and open source nature adapts them to new needs and technology trends.

Laravel framework installation method Laravel framework installation method Apr 18, 2025 pm 12:54 PM

Article summary: This article provides detailed step-by-step instructions to guide readers on how to easily install the Laravel framework. Laravel is a powerful PHP framework that speeds up the development process of web applications. This tutorial covers the installation process from system requirements to configuring databases and setting up routing. By following these steps, readers can quickly and efficiently lay a solid foundation for their Laravel project.

How to learn Laravel How to learn Laravel for free How to learn Laravel How to learn Laravel for free Apr 18, 2025 pm 12:51 PM

Want to learn the Laravel framework, but suffer from no resources or economic pressure? This article provides you with free learning of Laravel, teaching you how to use resources such as online platforms, documents and community forums to lay a solid foundation for your PHP development journey from getting started to master.

How to view the version number of laravel? How to view the version number of laravel How to view the version number of laravel? How to view the version number of laravel Apr 18, 2025 pm 01:00 PM

The Laravel framework has built-in methods to easily view its version number to meet the different needs of developers. This article will explore these methods, including using the Composer command line tool, accessing .env files, or obtaining version information through PHP code. These methods are essential for maintaining and managing versioning of Laravel applications.

What versions of laravel are there? How to choose the version of laravel for beginners What versions of laravel are there? How to choose the version of laravel for beginners Apr 18, 2025 pm 01:03 PM

In the Laravel framework version selection guide for beginners, this article dives into the version differences of Laravel, designed to assist beginners in making informed choices among many versions. We will focus on the key features of each release, compare their pros and cons, and provide useful advice to help beginners choose the most suitable version of Laravel based on their skill level and project requirements. For beginners, choosing a suitable version of Laravel is crucial because it can significantly impact their learning curve and overall development experience.

The difference between laravel and thinkphp The difference between laravel and thinkphp Apr 18, 2025 pm 01:09 PM

Laravel and ThinkPHP are both popular PHP frameworks and have their own advantages and disadvantages in development. This article will compare the two in depth, highlighting their architecture, features, and performance differences to help developers make informed choices based on their specific project needs.

See all articles