Beyond Causal Language Modeling
NeurIPS 2024 Spotlight: Optimizing Language Model Pretraining with Selective Language Modeling (SLM)
Recently, I presented a fascinating paper from NeurIPS 2024, "Not All Tokens Are What You Need for Pretraining," at a local reading group. This paper tackles a surprisingly simple yet impactful question: Is next-token prediction necessary for every token during language model pretraining?
The standard approach involves massive web-scraped datasets and applying causal language modeling (CLM) universally. This paper challenges that assumption, proposing that some tokens hinder, rather than help, the learning process. The authors demonstrate that focusing training on "useful" tokens significantly improves data efficiency and downstream task performance. This post summarizes their core ideas and key experimental findings.
The Problem: Noise and Inefficient Learning
Large web corpora inevitably contain noise. While document-level filtering helps, noise often resides within individual documents. These noisy tokens waste computational resources and potentially confuse the model.
The authors analyzed token-level learning dynamics, categorizing tokens based on their cross-entropy loss trajectory:
- L→L (Low to Low): Quickly learned, providing minimal further benefit.
- H→L (High to Low): Initially difficult, but eventually learned; representing valuable learning opportunities.
- H→H (High to High): Consistently difficult, often due to inherent unpredictability (aleatoric uncertainty).
- L→H (Low to High): Initially learned, but later become problematic, possibly due to context shifts or noise.
Their analysis reveals that only a small fraction of tokens provide meaningful learning signals.
The Solution: Selective Language Modeling (SLM)
The proposed solution, Selective Language Modeling (SLM), offers a more targeted approach:
-
Reference Model (RM) Training: A high-quality subset of the data is used to fine-tune a pre-trained base model, creating a reference model (RM). This RM acts as a benchmark for token "usefulness."
-
Excess Loss Calculation: For each token in the large corpus, the difference between the RM's loss and the current training model's loss (the "excess loss") is calculated. Higher excess loss indicates greater potential for improvement.
-
Selective Backpropagation: The full forward pass is performed on all tokens, but backpropagation only occurs for the top k% of tokens with the highest excess loss. This dynamically focuses training on the most valuable tokens.
Experimental Results: Significant Gains
SLM demonstrates significant advantages across various experiments:
-
Math Domain: On OpenWebMath, SLM achieved up to 10% performance gains on GSM8K and MATH benchmarks compared to standard CLM, reaching baseline performance 5-10 times faster. A 7B model matched a state-of-the-art model using only 3% of its training tokens. Fine-tuning further boosted performance by over 40% for a 1B model.
-
General Domain: Even with a strong pre-trained base model, SLM yielded approximately 5.8% average improvement across 15 benchmarks, particularly in challenging domains like code and math.
-
Self-Referencing: Even a quickly trained RM from the raw corpus provided a 2-3% accuracy boost and a 30-40% reduction in tokens used.
Conclusion and Future Work
This paper offers valuable insights into token-level learning dynamics and introduces SLM, a highly effective technique for optimizing language model pretraining. Future research directions include scaling SLM to larger models, exploring API-based reference models, integrating reinforcement learning, using multiple reference models, and aligning SLM with safety and truthfulness considerations. This work represents a significant advancement in efficient and effective language model training.
The above is the detailed content of Beyond Causal Language Modeling. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Hot AI Tools

Undresser.AI Undress
AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover
Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Undress AI Tool
Undress images for free

Clothoff.io
AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap
Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Article

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1
Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version
Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1
Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6
Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version
God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

Hot Topics











Meta's Llama 3.2: A Leap Forward in Multimodal and Mobile AI Meta recently unveiled Llama 3.2, a significant advancement in AI featuring powerful vision capabilities and lightweight text models optimized for mobile devices. Building on the success o

Hey there, Coding ninja! What coding-related tasks do you have planned for the day? Before you dive further into this blog, I want you to think about all your coding-related woes—better list those down. Done? – Let’

This week's AI landscape: A whirlwind of advancements, ethical considerations, and regulatory debates. Major players like OpenAI, Google, Meta, and Microsoft have unleashed a torrent of updates, from groundbreaking new models to crucial shifts in le

Shopify CEO Tobi Lütke's recent memo boldly declares AI proficiency a fundamental expectation for every employee, marking a significant cultural shift within the company. This isn't a fleeting trend; it's a new operational paradigm integrated into p

Introduction Imagine walking through an art gallery, surrounded by vivid paintings and sculptures. Now, what if you could ask each piece a question and get a meaningful answer? You might ask, “What story are you telling?

Introduction OpenAI has released its new model based on the much-anticipated “strawberry” architecture. This innovative model, known as o1, enhances reasoning capabilities, allowing it to think through problems mor

SQL's ALTER TABLE Statement: Dynamically Adding Columns to Your Database In data management, SQL's adaptability is crucial. Need to adjust your database structure on the fly? The ALTER TABLE statement is your solution. This guide details adding colu

For those of you who might be new to my column, I broadly explore the latest advances in AI across the board, including topics such as embodied AI, AI reasoning, high-tech breakthroughs in AI, prompt engineering, training of AI, fielding of AI, AI re
